Ask any western physician where the roots of his craft might lie and inevitably he or she will cite the ancient masters, and point straight to the cradle of western civilization. Indeed, every freshly graduated doctor pledges to the Hippocratic oath, or a modern version thereof. This oath, ascribed to the great physician Hippocrates, is a timeless code of ethics devised to keep the profession noble and pure. Sadly, its high moral standards are far too often compromised in modern practice, but that is another matter and shall be discussed another time.
Greece - the cradle of civilization, as it is so often called. That is supposed to be where the roots of modern medicine lie. Indeed, many threads lead to Greece, to the altars of Asclepius of Hygieia and Panaceia, the ancient Gods of the healing arts. But the story of western medicine is a far more entangled web. The roots have long distance 'runners', to borrow another botanical term.
What we have come to know as classic Greek medicine is a melange of ideas from many far-flung places of the ancient world. In those distant days scholars were eager to learn and to travel, to exchange ideas and discuss their philosophies with one another and their counterparts of foreign cultures. Thus it came to be that philosophies from Egypt, India and the Arab world became intricately and inseparable intertwined with the ancient Greek medical philosophy.
The Greeks regarded the known universe as a composition of four elements, two 'male'- fire and air, and two 'female' elements - earth and water. Each element's essential nature expresses itself to a greater or lesser degree in the world of natural phenomena, including the symptoms of disease. In the body these elements were represented by the corresponding 'humours': Sanguis or Blood, (air) is warm and moist; Phlegm, (water) is cold and moist; Choler or Yellow Bile (fire) is warm and dry and Melancholer or Black Bile (earth) is cold and dry. The fifth element, aether or spirit was non-material, yet it permeated and animated everything in existence.
It was Galen (125 - 199AD) who popularised and enshrined these philosophies for centuries to come, though they were originally attributed to Hippocrates (400 BC). Some scholars, however, believe that the Hippocratic writings are a collection of teachings by different authors. Significantly they arose during the same period in which Alexander the Great reached India. It seems more than likely that western medical philosophy received a large infusion of inspiration from Ayurvedic teachings.
As with the Ayurvedic system, the Greek philosophers also created correspondences between the humours and the organs of the body, temperaments and seasons etc.
|Blood||spring||air||liver||warm & moist||sanguine||courageous, hopeful, amorous|
|Phlegm||winter||water||brain/lungs||cold & moist||phlegmatic,||calm, unemotional|
|Yellow bile||summer||fire||gall bladder||warm & dry||choleric||easily angered, bad tempered|
|Black bile||autumn||earth||spleen||cold & dry||melancholic||despondant, sleepless, irritable|
The humours also indicated certain temperamental dispositions, as in fact they still do - we still talk about sanguine, choleric, phlegmatic or melancholic temperaments.
Sanguine Temperament - corresponds to the element of air. Characteristics include a fair to ruddy, well developed muscles, large full veins and a large pulse. They are optimistic, confident and extravert types who are rarely anxious. They like being physically active and often overdo it and thus are prone to suffer sports injuries and other accidents.
Phlegmatic Temperament - corresponds to the element of water. Characteristics include a fair complexion, light hair, general softness and lack of muscle tone. The skin can feel cool and moist. The pulse is soft and wide. Excessive metabolic activity tends to draw heat inwards leaving the exterior cold. This type is prone to feeling cold. The Phlegmatic type is slow and sluggish, and does easily get excited. There is a tendency to put on weight.
Choleric Temperament - corresponds to the element of fire. Characteristics include a slim, wiry body frame. The skin may be yellowish and feel oily. They are prone to excessive nervous activity, think quickly but can't concentrate. These types are passionate and easily become angry or excited, but their fuming evaporates in a puff. They live on their nerves and their adrenaline and are therefore susceptible to mental and nervous disorders such as anxiety. Their pulse tends to be sharp and quick.
Melancholic Temperament - Belongs to Earth element and usually has a darkish complexion and appears boney. The skin may be dry, the hair brittle. The metabolism is slow, their energy level low. This temperament tends towards a serious state of mind and is prone to depression.
Of course this is just a rudimentary characterisation. The ancients applied astrology to their medical art and considered each individual according to their planetary merits. Indeed, it was Hippocrates who said "He who does not understand astrology is not a doctor but a fool. - this opinion apparently was shared by many of his fellow" doctors, even until quite recent times. It was only in the late 18th century that medicine and astrology parted for good.
According to the doctrine of humors disease was the result of an imbalance between the bodily fluids (distemper). To adjust the balance various methods of treatment were considered, but, as in Ayurveda, the first strategy was to implement dietary adjustments. An excess of phlegm for example would call for foods that could be considered 'warm and dry'. If these did not work other methods, such as blood letting or purging were tried, according to the specific imbalance of the patient.
|Causes of Warm or Hot Dystemper||Symptoms|
|Causes of Moist Dystemper||Symptoms|
|Causes of Cold Dystemper||Symptoms|
|Causes of Dry Dystemper||Symptoms|
Hardly surprising, a huge canon of correspondences soon emerged, along with endless arguments regarding the 'hotness' 'dryness' coldness' or 'wetness' of various substances, which culminated in Galen's attempt to create some sort of coherent system, categorizing each substances by its degrees of heat, moisture, dryness or coldness. His work, although religiously followed for several centuries to come, transmuted the sublime into the ridiculous and eventually Paracelsus was the first to publicly question the ancient doctrine and, - gasp - , to burn the old books.
However, Paracelsus was not adverse to the idea of elements and his own writings are full of metaphysical concepts that heavily draw on alchemical symbolism borrowed from the ancients. owever, there is a difference between seeing the essential nature of a thing or disease with the perceptions of the inner eye, and following blindly the doctrine of a systematic categorization scheme that superimposes a rigid categorization rather than trying to understand the symbolic essence.
The system later became known as the 'doctrine of signatures', a system of references, which sought the symbolic key to understanding the world of appearances and blended the teaching of 'likenesses' with that of 'correspondences'. This doctrine and the whole idea of correspondences became discredited and today survives only as mythology - and as secret teachings in certain occult circles.
Yet, the original Hippocratic teachings actually provide a blueprint for a holistic approach to western medicine, a system that seeks to understand the body as a socio-spiritual body/mind entity.
Environmental factors that could predispose to development of certain symptoms were considered just as much as diet or profession, or the mental and emotional constitution. A patient was regarded within his physical and spiritual context - through astrology - a fundamental aspect of these ancient teachings that modern practitioners prefer to ignore or deny. Today most of these teachings have been lost. They only survive as obscure branch of astrology - medical astrology. Neither modern medicine, which prides itself of its ancient roots, nor holistic medicine acknowledges these cosmological ties. Yet, increasingly, patients and doctors are becoming dissatisfied with a mechanistic model of medicine as we struggle to formulate a medical practice that acknowledges the soul's existence and role in our physical well-being. Perhaps the ancients were right, and the answers lie obviously hidden...in the stars.
For questions or comments email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Please note that all materials presented here are copyrighted. You may download it for your personal use or forward it to your friends or anybody you think might be interested, but please send
it in its entirety and quote the source. Any other reuse or publication of our content is only permitted with expressed permission of the author.
Please send comments or inquiries to Sacred Earth.
This Article was originally published in the Sacred Earth Newletter. The Newsletter is a FREE service containing articles, news and reviews on all things herbal and/or ethnobotanical, with an approximate publication cylce of 6 - 8 weeks. If you wish to subscribe, please use the subscription box to submit your e-mail address.
Please note that although all the references to edible and medicinal herbs are tried and tested, their efficacy cannot be guaranteed and has not been approved by the FDA. Furthermore, everybody responds differently to various plants, and adverse reactions cannot be ruled out. Historical information regarding poisonous plants is included for educational purposes only and should not be tried out at home. Everybody uses herbs at their own risk and thus must make themselves fully aware of their potential power. Any information given here is educational and should not replace a visit to the doctor should this be necessary. Neither Sacred Earth nor Kat Morgenstern accepts responsibility for anybody's home experimentation. Links to external sites are included as pointers to further resources - we do not endorse them or are in any way responsible for their content, nor do we thus verify that their content is accurate.